Showing posts with label corporal punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label corporal punishment. Show all posts

Monday, February 13, 2012

Why Kids First Isn't The Best Policy

Disclaimer: I don't have kids. I don't like kids. I don't want kids. 'Nough said.

There is a push in the land of America to put all kids "first". Now, in principle, I understand this concept. Raise a child in the best possible environment with all of the love and affection they can stand to make a better human adult. The trouble is, it's bullshit.
More to the point, it's gone way too far. Parents are indulging their little monsters to the point of raising a self-absorbed, pouty, self-indulgent, whiny, little turd for whom the words "discipline" and "responsibility", not to mention "courtesy" and "respect", mean nothing. Failure is always an option in the great competition for status, money, and power we call life, but heaven forbid someones' little angel 'fail' at something for fear of bruising their fragile, little egos. The parents become indignant that their underachieving brat is shown to the world to be, well, an underachieving brat, and storm the bastions of education we call "public school" with a demand that their adorable idiot be allowed to pass.

Life doesn't work that way.

And speaking of public education, let's look at how the concept of "no child left behind" has fucked up the entire U.S. educational system.

Despite the desire on the parts of do-gooders to believe otherwise, children are, indeed, like adults. In other words, you have bright ones and dumb ones. Don't talk to me about their "potential". Everyone "potential" is set in stone the moment they're born. A dumb kid IS going to work retail, at best. (Unless they're born into a family with political connections in which case, they'll be called "Bush" and babysat throughout their careers by older puppet-masters, but I digress...). A smart kid MIGHT work retail. That's about the only sure difference. But in that narrow maze of smart and dumb, there is a wide gap in mental ability - which means the smart ones will do very well in school and the dumb ones can't. So how do you keep from leaving anyone behind? You have to dummy it all down so the dumb ones can keep up.

Looking over at the smart ones while all this dummying down is going on, they're no longer engaged in the lessons. When they're spinning differential equations in their head but the material is still mastering one plus one for the idiots in the classes, they're going to lose interest. And when the smart ones have no chance to out-perform the dumb ones with special rewards for outstanding achievement, their eventual arrival in the land of retail becomes more likely. Positive reinforcement is the best way to teach. But when everyone gets a reward regardless of their level of work in order to not single out the idiots in the class who can't really compete to avoid damaging their sense of self esteem, the whole concept of a reward goes out the window.

And let's not kid ourselves about rewards here. If you take an outstanding student and give them "something" for their achievement, then give "something else" to the other, under-preforming kids, you just undermined that reward for outstanding achievement. It's tainted because it's no longer a unique event. People try to kid themselves that differing the reward has any positive impact on the child. Imagine an Olympics were everyone got medals “just for trying”. It degrades the accomplishments of the winners. That decreases the incentive to “win”.

Everyone can't be winners all the time.

So what happens is that you have a whole generation of people who were raised in an environment where no one was allowed to fail, who are then thrust into the real world where failure is always an option? You get a shit-ton of pathetic whiners. Is it any wonder that the products of this environment enjoy movies and celebrities exhibiting nihilistic, self-absorbed, self-indulgent, pouty natures? (Like Vampires, werewolves and Lindsey Lohan).

The bottom line is that kids need to be shown the consequences of failure at a time when failure doesn't mean putting them on the streets, in a hospital, in rehab or in jail like it does in the real world. Kids need to be shown that making a mistake has consequences - real ones - and to show that failure is one of the best teaching methods to actually learn something of value. Flunk them if they don't do the work. Hold them back in grade level if they aren't applying themselves or lack the mental ability to go on. Don't dummy down the material but brain it up to the highest point that the child can stand. Challenge them to excel and hold them to that expectation. Failure should have consequences worth avoiding, but also should be shown to be an opportunity to learn.

And for heaven's sake, stop giving out awards for finger-painting, citizenship and other BS garbage where everyone is intended to feel good about failing. Failure should hurt. Fail big, it should hurt big. And when you win big, well, in life the fact is, when you win big, the congratulations only last a short time, so teach them to keep reaching for their goals. Winning should be its own reward and the way people are taught should be geared toward that idea.

The idea here is to teach responsibility and discipline. Teach kids how to THINK, not just how to take tests and "not fail". Everyone fails - some more than others and some bigger than others. Someone wins and that win is recognized until someone else wins. Teaching that failure is always an option will help people learn discipline and responsibility. You don't always win with a sense of responsibility and self-discipline, but you are far more likely to fail without them.

It may go against the grain of the do-gooders to teach this to kids, but the truth is, life leaves people behind. Education by idealistic slogan is a failure for both the child and society. LEAVE some behind and let society deal with them. If the ones who are going to get ahead are encouraged to do so, they may actually do something for those left behind. But when those who are better than those who would be left behind are treated the same as those who would be left behind, they lose interest. Mediocrity becomes the new "best". And society suffers all the more for it.

What's worse, kids today (at least those I've encountered all over the country in America), are, by and large, the rudest little shits on the planet. They are self-absorbed, self-entitled, self-indulgent monsters running amok with the parents looking on with apparent delight in their child's inability to get along with anyone else. Apparently, parents today (at least most of them, it seems) believe that being respectful and courteous toward others is some kind of handicap. It's not "being strong and independent" in their eyes.
A strong person doesn't need to prove they're strong and being discourteous, rude, whiny little shits in public only tells me that there is yet another asshole on the freeway, bully in the classroom, back-stabbing fucker at work and a bar-fight to be in the making. It also tells me that the parents should have been "fixed" before they had kids because these asocial creatures, and likely their get, will do little to nothing to contribute to the human race in any way whatsoever.

Wastes of DNA.

Children need discipline. They need structure. They need limits. It's not going to bruise their little egos if you, as a parent, impose a little of each. Just keep in mind the word, "moderation".

Discipline for a child includes two things: Punishment and reward. Punishment MUST be painful, but applied proportionately and not always physically. Rewards should be very small for small things and very large for large things. There can be only a few absolutes. The idea is to teach your child that hard work is most often rewarded and doing bad things is most often punished.

And above all, this has to start EARLY in the child's life. Suddenly being confronted by a mouthy, disrespectful tween isn't an accident. It's negligence on the part of the parent. Being independent doesn't mean being rude or discourteous.

I DO believe in spanking a child, but I don't believe in HITTING one. Spanking is to be reserved for the worst things a child does, and must always be accompanied by other lesser punishments like grounding, denial of access to favored toys, enforced curfews, etc. A spanking is most effective when it is meted out sparingly, preceded by a talk explaining what's coming and why, giving the child time to think about it, then administering the punishment and reinforcing the lesson with another talking to afterward. It is the epitome of punishments, one meant to instill fear of it in the child and is to be used only when all other punishments have failed.

If they still act out, sell them to gypsies or put them in a burlap bag and drown them like kittens. They'll bring you nothing but misery the rest of your life, otherwise.

In all seriousness, kids must have structure and limits, be taught self discipline, respect and manners. They must learn to do this for everyone, and not just a favored few. That means the PARENTS need to do it, too, because nothing fucks up a kid's head like being told one thing by their parents then seeing them do something entirely different.

They resent the hypocrisy, even if they don't know that it's called hypocrisy. If you tell the kid not to lie, never lie to them. If you teach them to keep promises, keep your promises to them (and others, for that matter). YOU set the standard of THEIR behavior, and they will do what you do. If you don't like what you see in your kid, chances are, others don't like what they see in you. If people don't like what they see in you, you can bet your last dollar they hate your kids because they act the same way as you do.

If you have the attitude, "Kids will be kids", you're dead wrong. Kids will be ADULTS, and a hell of a lot sooner than you think. If people are bitching about your little angels, you have a problem and you can see who caused it in the damn mirror.

The purpose of having kids isn't a trophy for you to parade around. It isn't to fulfill some inexplicable need or hole in YOUR life (because 18 years later, that hole is there again when they leave the nest, and you've solved nothing). It isn't an "accomplishment" to be proud of since just about everyone on EARTH does it at some point, many doing it way too often.

The purpose of having kids is to prepare the human race for the next generation. That means teaching them how to get along, cooperate, think, reason, work as an individual and work together. THAT'S how mankind made it as far as we have. And that's the ONLY way mankind will survive our technologically-laced adolescence.
Kids first isn't the best policy because it puts mankind and the planet behind them. Put mankind and the planet first, raise your kids up right to become contributing and welcome members of our society and they will go and do things for which you CAN be justifiably proud.

Monday, December 12, 2011

It's High Time to Bring Back the Shed

I was reading an article in the local paper about two 16 year old boys who have been bound over for trial for abducting, beating and raping two teenaged girls. I couldn't help but think about how much we as a society spend on feeding, clothing and housing these wastes of existence and wondered why people keep doing this stuff.

Then it dawned on me: People are, of course, animals. Hell, we've only had about 10,000 years of domestication. Dogs have been human companions for at least 25,000 years and they still attack and kill their owners at times and they're not nearly as smart as we are. (Then again, if you think about it, they get free food and shelter for the cost of a little stick chasing. Not bad for "unintelligent animals". But I digress...)

The point is, we need something much more effective than housing criminals. Prisons are just breeding grounds for creating more capable felons. Recidivism (that's being arrested again after being released from prison) in the U.S. runs between 60 and 80%. Obviously, as a deterrence to crime, prison holds no fear for anyone.

So my proposal in my more lucid moments is to bring back the Shed.

Way back in my youth, we talked in hushed and frightful tones about being taken "behind the shed". This was always where punishment was meted out by a wide, leather belt to the behind for a number of strokes in proportion to the severity of the transgression. It was something to avoid. It was something to fear.

That kind of fear is what needs to be instilled in the minds of the public who decide to transgress the laws of the land. Prison is uncomfortable but it's not designed to be PAINFUL. The human animal is designed to avoid pain. Pain HURTS. It's nature's way of saying "Don't do this!". It's basic and elementary. It impacts the animal in everyone and every living thing. Inflict pain and that memory lingers.

Of course, beating a dog has to be done quickly because the lesson - why they're getting beaten - doesn't correlate well if there's been a long period of time between the transgression and the punishment unless the punishment is meted out with a reminder of what not to do (Like rubbing the dog's nose in the mess it made). With people, it's a little different, to some extent. The human animal is able to know why it's being punished even years after the fact, but sometimes that's not quite enough.

So let's bring back the shed, only put it on television and make it a public affair. Sell tickets, or even have free admission to the viewing public. I'd make it mandatory viewing at least once a year if someone wants to drive or register to vote. (I'm pretty sure the registering to vote thing would be problematic, but you could add it as a requirement for driving, vehicle registration or any other thing that's done annually.) This way EVERYONE sees it. EVERYONE knows what will happen when you transgress society: You're taken "behind the shed" by Uncle Sam, who beats the living crap out of you, and maybe beats some sense INTO you.

But why make Uncle Sam the heavy in this? Yes, these people transgress the laws of society, so society can exact its punishment, but these transgressions, more often than not, involve real, actual people. Certainly those two teenaged girls are real people deserving of their full share of justice - if not retribution.

So my proposal is further modified to include a mandatory minimum number of lashes, with the victim(s) of the convicted criminal meting out their measure until they feel justice has been served.

Now, to keep this from turning into a bloodbath, there ARE some limits to this (I'm not THAT much of an animal... Well, yes I am, but I like to be somewhat reasonable about it.). First of all, we create a lashing machine that can be calibrated to the physiology of the criminal so that regardless of how many times they're lashed, no permanent damage (maybe just scarring) will ever result. Limits would be placed on it to keep anyone from actually dying.

Another limit would be to keep the lashes to once every five seconds, instead of incessantly beating them over and over without a pause.

But the goal of the machine would be to inflict a measured and rational amount of pain on the criminal per stroke.

Finally, to make this "humane", we can establish a metric whereby someone beaten receives a maximum amount of pain with a minimum amount of lasting physical damage.

The simple fact is that humans require a great deal of incentive to change their ways. We are creatures of habit and if we get into the habit of being utter asses, then we will be asses until we come up with good reasons not to be like that. Pain is how creatures big and small avoid doing things that inflict that pain. People aren't terribly bright most of the time, but USUALLY they can figure out that if X behavior results in Y pain, they will stop doing X behavior.

So I say bring back the Shed. Bring back that terrifying time behind the shed for everyone convicted of a crime regardless of age. They WILL LEARN not to do that again. It's an instinctive act to avoid pain. If our penal system was as catering to our instincts as it is to our sensibilities, we'd never, ever have another repeat offender.