"You gotta have faith" as the George Michaels song goes.
To me, not so damn much.
Here's the reason: Faith is bad for ya.
Actually, faith is bad for everyone, if one stipulates several extremely obvious facts.
Fact 1: People are stupid. Half of the population is below average in IQ. If this isn't self-evident to you, then please stop reading right now and get sterilized, then shoot any kids you have in the head because you are too fucking stupid to be allowed to breed.
Fact 2: MOST people think they're above average. Since this is statistically impossible, there are a large number of seriously deluded people who are out there fucking with the rest of us.
Fact 3: Faith requires the rejection of rationality in order to maintain. If you think being irrational is a great way to live, please re-read Fact 1 and follow the advice there.
Fact 4: People are unwilling to admit when they're wrong to the point of violence.
For the purposes of clarification, faith is the unfounded and unquestioning belief in something. That something can be anything from your spouse's faithfulness to the deity du jour you happen to believe in today. You have no proof. You have no direct knowledge. You just have faith.
And very often, you're wrong about these things.
I'm not requiring or demanding perfection here. People are wrong about a lot of things. People make mistakes. That's okay. It's part of living and life. But it's when you're always wrong, yet not only insist you're right, you demand others join you in your mistake that gets my panties in a bunch.
"I'm not wrong about my faith!" you scream at the top of your lungs.
Yes, in fact, you are and here's why.
Historically, mankind has had many different religious faiths. Today, there are basically three: Judaism, Islam and Christianity. Atheism isn't a faith because they don't believe in anything. It's not a disbelief of your idea of whatever your faith happens to be. It not believing in it in the first place. If you equate disbelief with belief, then you see the first example of Fact 3 about those who have faith. Those who have faith believe in "something". That is what faith is all about. Those who don't believe in that something, but a different something, have a different faith. Those who don't believe in any "somethings" have no faith. A lack of faith in somethings means no faith in a something. Since only those who have faith in a something can have faith, those who don't do not have a faith.
One might argue that not believing in something is a faith. One would be wrong. It takes faith to believe in something in the first place. A faithless person doesn't believe in what a person of faith believes in. A person who believes in something is the one saying there is the something to believe in in the first place. The difference between this form of psychosis and a nut on the street is the number of people sharing the same irrational delusion that the something in which they believe, for which they have no proof, no evidence, no way to legitimately and objectively substantiate their illusions, actually exists.
But is this why you're wrong about your faith? Yes, in part. This is because NO ONE IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND HAS BEEN RIGHT.
Let's look at the whole of mankind's existence.
We started out with Unk, or Og, or Ub or some other such monosyllabic name for some imagined "god" who controlled something we didn't then understand. Little things like the weather, the earth, the sun, the stars and, well, pretty much everything else we encounter in our lives even today. We wondered where we came from. We wondered why we were here. So we mixed in a lot of guess work, a touch of philosophy and started a little thing called Religion. What religions asked for you was faith to take what these explanations for these things were (like gods and evils causing good andevil things to happen) at face value. To NOT QUESTION THEM.
Bad, bad move.
Then someone came along and came up with a "better" explanation. Of course, it was another god, or another rationalization with some philosophic overtone. Then some slightly brighter than normal people realized that other people sucked this stuff up like water to a thirsty person and decided to invest in it, reaping both secular power and wealth in the process.
You don't HONESTLY think the Catholic church is one of the wealthiest organizations on the face of the planet because they're saving souls, do you? Ever heard of their vow of poverty? If they believed it, the Pope would live no better than some street urchin in Cambodia. Please don't insult the rest of us who can think with your rationalizations justifying this.
Speaking of rationalizations, along comes another rationalization, and the faiths changed yet again. "Gosh, my faith didn't sound as good as this one does," people say to themselves and switch. More often, they switched thinking, "Hey, it doesn't matter who I give lip service to as long as I'm taken care of in the afterlife and I really don't want this driveling idiot fucktard to kill me for sticking with what I've believed all my life."
At the point of a sword, gun or by better rationalizations, faiths have been changed time and time and time again over the course of human history.
So why do you fucking think you've got it right THIS time?
"We've been believing this shit for thousands of years," you say.
Yeah, well, so did the Egyptians, the Norse, the Sumerians and the Greeks and Romans. Do you think we're worshiping the Sun God Apollo? Monotheism is just another rationalization foisted upon us by those seeking secular power and wealth over us.
It's all the same bullshit, served up with different garnishes.
So you are WRONG in your faith if you are one of the big three. In fact, you're probably wrong even if you're not one of the big three. If it relies on a rationalization instead of logic, it's certain to be wrong.
By the way, for the rationally challenged out there, this is an example of a little thing we who can think clearly and rationally call "logic". That's another thing you're functionally unequipped to deal with.
So, aside from a shared delusion, what's the harm? After all, Will Farrell is considered a good actor by a large number of people. A similar number of people thought "The Hangover" was high comedy.
Please see Fact 1 for the reason this happens. Please follow the advice for Fact 1 if you happen to be among those who don't think otherwise.
To be honest, it's not the irrationality or stupidity that is the major problem with faith. It isn't even the fact that people can't think rationally. Those factors are merely the predisposition held by those individuals who are afflicted by the phenomenon of faith. While I personally feel that the stupid shouldn't breed as a major favor to the future of humanity (mostly because they'll always remain susceptible to manipulation by those smarter than they are), it's not their lack of brain power that is the problem. Faith is the problem.
So why is faith the problem?
Faith is a problem because people believe in it and talk about it.
Really, that's the bottom line in this. It doesn't much matter if ONE person is irrational. It matters greatly when more than one person shares the same delusion. This is because they do NOT share the SAME ONE.
This concept is a touch difficult to follow, but bear with me for a while.
First of all, people are individuals. They have individual thoughts. They see the world from different perspectives. They sense the world in slightly different ways. Some hear better, some see better, things like that. And we all have things in our lives that impact the way we think from hormones to what we ate (or didn't eat). So although we may think we believe and have faith in the same things, we do not see them, experience them, or even think about them in the same way.
This is born out by the number of religions we have today. Look at the Protestant religion. A thousand faiths and growing almost hourly. People who can't agree with the dogma make up their own. (This also plays into the fact that your faith is wrong. What part of it don't you like? Why haven't you changed it? Others have.) They don't think about it the same way. They don't experience it the same way. It's different for everyone in some way.
Diminishing returns makes faith INHERENTLY an individualistic thing. Since you can't possibly know what someone else is thinking or EXACTLY how they experience it, you can only guess and chances are great your guess will be wrong. Faith is based entirely on guesswork and is founded by the notion that it's not okay to not know. Since when did "I don't know" become a "sin"? People aren't born with knowledge. They learn it as they go. Taking short-cuts by blindly accepting rationalizations only subverts the learning process and undermines knowledge.
So people don't see things the same way, and still think they're all following the same idea. Talk about demented.
Groups of people are dangerous in and of themselves. Why? See Fact 1.
More to the point, groups identify among themselves. Their ersatz commonalities based on these rationalizations give them a cohesion that would otherwise be absent. I mean, let's face it, if you didn't meet them in your church, or think they shared your faith, would you even bother knowing most of them? Would you even give two shits about them? You probably say, of course. Now, turn that around, WHY DON'T YOU GIVE THE SAME TWO SHITS ABOUT EVERY OTHER STRANGER? See what I mean about how a group dynamic is a bad thing? You're part of one group. That other stranger is part of another group who doesn't believe the same nonsense as you believe in. That creates an artificial difference between you and "everyone else". Your faith in that rationalization separating you from other strangers who don't believe the same myth as you is what turns you against them, and them against you.
(That inherent trust and group cohesion, by the way, is why con artists are most often church-goers fleecing the flock. You trust them because they share your faith. What a fucking moron you are to do that and you deserve to lose every penny you do (or did). Blame the group dynamic and your misplaced trust in your faith for it.)
So, toss in a bunch of rationalizations that inflict what others believe to be indignities on people who don't think the same way with that group dynamic, and you have a recipe for disaster.
We get repression of women, repression of men, repression of sex, repression of... Well, pretty much everything, if you were to follow every faith in the world. You wouldn't be able to eat meat, harm anyone (except, of course, non-believers), unless those anyones were committing some "sin" in which case you are allowed to stone them to death or beat them with a rod no thicker than your thumb. Oh, and don't forget it's not nice to own slaves who are countrymen, so be sure to own slaves from out of the country, but be sure they are properly documented or you could be jailed for abetting illegals.
I mean, seriously, people, what kind of twisted, fucked in the head thinking do you have to have to think you're RIGHT about ANYTHING involving blind faith? Others have exactly the same amount of faith in their twisted, fucked in the head rationalizations as YOU do. No single rationalization can possibly be correct. The alternatives are that all of them are correct or none of them are. Based on the fact none of them have been correct so far, it's pretty safe to conclude that none of them are.
Between a group dynamic that demonizes others who are not part of the group, the misconception of the faith by, literally, everyone IN that faith, and the fact that people are stupid (plus the other facts previously stipulated), we end up with a world that is fucked in the head and will likely stay that way until we abolish faith and start working on fact.
We're always going to have stupid people, until that average comes up, then we'll have smart people and really smart people. But because stupid people think they're above average, them not breeding isn't going to happen soon enough to save the species. So we need to get rid of faith. If it has to be explained in paranormal terms, using superstition and mythology, forget it. If you don't have a strong and overt element of doubt, and don't remain willing to entertain such doubts, you need to be "fixed" like Spot and Fluffy.
So all this begs the question: Do I have faith.
Not a blind one - which is what we're talking about here. I'm open to suggestion. I'm willing to say I may be wrong should someone be able to show me a more rational, reasonable, fact-based means of exploring that which we humans call the "spiritual". But I don't believe in afterlives - consciousness after death. I'm not entirely convinced we have a "soul", either. There's no evidence for it, but it's impossible to prove the non-existence of something. One has to prove it exists before proof exists one way or another.
Part of why I'm so against blind faith is this little fact: No proof of nonexistence. Someone asserts they believe in something - like a god - then says I have to prove it doesn't exist. Wrong order. They must prove it exists since they're the ones making the claim it does. Then they say they have to have faith that it exists, because if they don't have faith it exists, but KNOW it exists, then there would be no faith, so it wouldn't exist. The trouble is that the utter lack of rationality in this circular argument is lost on them. If it exists in the first place, why muck around with "faith"? To "accept it"? Hey, people don't accept the President of the United States and he certainly exists. So proof of existence isn't even remotely a hindrance to willful rejection.
And if some deity was actually all powerful and such, why would it allow all of the shit and strife we have in the world today over whether it even exists in the first place?
The places for gods to hide, where we can look at something, see what it's all about and understand it's not supernatural, it's not "god", but it's just the way the world is are growing smaller and smaller. We aren't here because gods created us and created this "perfect" world for us to fuck with. We're here because of a long line of improbable accidents. Then someone will say, "Well, God was behind those accidents." I say no, because last week, before we discovered we could prove we're here because of these accidents, you were saying we're here because God made us and our Perfect world for us and didn't say shit about these accidents.
If you know so fucking much, why didn't you mention that before?
It's a rationalization and you will NOT accept that you're wrong because of Fact 4: People are unwilling to admit when they're wrong to the point of violence.
But I digress...
Okay, back to faith.
Having faith and sharing it is a bad thing. Politicians and religious leaders rely on it to get their power on earth over you. Have no faith in people. Have no faith in rationalizations. Have faith in things that are real, or at least be open do doubt in those gray areas where the "we don't know's" lurk instead of trying to fill them with the deity that, before that place was understood, used to be lord of lords and king of kings and almighty in the universe. The domain of blind faith in a coming age of reason will not go away quietly or peacefully because people of blind faith are actively working - and fighting - against reason to avoid the inevitable time when all is understood and there's no reason to have faith in the first place.
The arrogance these people display that they're right and everyone else is wrong is what pisses me off.
I'm just one person, who believes in being reasonable and rational. We have enough problems in the world without inventing bullshit reasons to make things worse. If you can't handle the way life is arranged, that's YOUR issue. Don't expect me, or anyone else to buy into your lack of adult perspective. Grow the fuck up, get a back-bone and stop wishing upon a star for shit that you can never be as sure about as you think you are.
And for all that YOU hold holy, don't breed. The faster we get rid of the genes of people who can have blind faith, the more likely the human race will actually survive.
Showing posts with label faith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label faith. Show all posts
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
U.S. Founded as a Christian Nation? Yeah... Right...
The Right Wing (Or the Evil Empire, take your pick in my book) has asserted, often loudly and with great reverence, that the United States was founded as a Christian Nation!
Not hardly...
It's Final Jeopardy and the category is: US Myths and Fallacies
The answer is, "All of them." You have thirty seconds. Please put your answer in the form of a question.
(30 seconds later)
Right wing, contestant number one, you have thirty trillion dollars and own 85% of the wealth of the United States. What was your answer?
Uh, I said, "How many of the Founding Fathers were Christians?"
Oh, I'm sorry, Right Wing. That is an incorrect answer. The Correct answer is "Which of the Founding Fathers were businessmen?"
That's right, boys and girls and all the ships at sea, our Founding Fathers were Businessmen first, liberals (yes, really, liberals, interested in freedom, democracy and wary of large tyrannical powers that sought to limit personal freedom and choice) and, mostly not too fond of religions.
Now, it must be pointed out that they were against ORGANIZED RELIGIONS. This is an important distinction. They believed in faith, but they adamantly refused to allow a personal faith to interfere in the business of creating a government. They went so far as to put that into the FIRST AMENDMENT in the bill of rights.
You see, organized religions have this habit of screwing up governments. As observed by Thomas Jefferson (you know, the guy who wrote the Declaration of Independence? Third President of the United States? Banged his own slave girl and fathered children with her? THAT Thomas Jefferson?) in a letter to German Baron von Humboldt in 1813:
Now, least you think that perhaps he was talking about corrput politicians and priests and not about religions in general or Christianity in particular, he went on to say at another time:
But let us go further and examine the right-wing notion that they were trying to do just that: create a Christian Nation.
They were crafting a nation. They only needed a 2/3 majority to get the work done. And all of the 13 original states had to sign onto the newly drafted Constitution. If we were a nation of people wanting it to be a Christian nation, why didn't they put it in the Constitution? Why, instead, did they specifically and categorically deny the right of the government to dictate what religion a person had. Not only that, but why did they put that prohibition against the government into the very FIRST amendment which became our Bill of Rights? Going one step further to pound this home, why did they make that the FIRST PROVISION OF THAT AMENDMENT IN THE BILL OF RIGHTS? If these were all good and godly men foaming at the mount to create the first truly Christian Nation, why did they go so far out of their way to shoot themselves in the foot on the journey to that religious destiny?
Well, the easy answer is because they weren't that interested in God. In fact, they were so not interested in God, that the word God doesn't appear in the Constitution. Nowhere. Not a peep. In fact, "deity", "Creator" or any reference to anything even remotely of a religious, let alone "christian" nature is glaringly absent from the Constitution - aside from the prohibition on the part of government to create laws based on one.
You think, maybe, they were sending a message?
To refresh your memory:
This isn't exactly what I would call "Christian Nation building" here.
The truth of the matter is that the founding fathers saw what the Church of England had done to the people in England (and elsewhere where other religions governed or had a strong hand in the running of a government). They knew that allowing any religion, regardless of who believed in it, or how many, to be able to take power in the government would be a disaster for the free, open society they envisioned.
So why were they so into a free and open society? Aside from a large dose of off-shore repression England engaged in before the Revolutionary war (and for a period of time thereafter, in fact), the founding fathers were BUSINESSMEN. Almost all of them were rich land-owners. Almost all of them were extremely well educated. Almost all of them owned businesses or were heavily invested in them.
In ANY society run by dogma, the clerics only need to decide something is subversive or immoral, then pass a law to outlaw it or restrict it. In a free and open society, people can smoke, drink and fool around howsoever they please. They can indulge in the vices the church often railed against: Smoking, drinking and fooling around. Many of the founding fathers owned (or were invested in) distilleries. Others owned tobacco plantations. Almost all of them owned slaves (something ELSE the churches hated and wanted abolished).
The founding fathers were creating a businessman's paradise, folks, NOT a nation of Christians. The LAST damned thing they wanted was some stupid church to get its meat hooks into the government to shut down their distilleries, make them stop harvesting tobacco (and hemp, by the way), or, heaven forbid, take away their slaves. Profits would plummet.
A cadre of "Christian Nation Builders" they were not.
So the next time you hear a right-winger talk about our found fathers as Christians interested in a Christian nation, you can do what I do: Laugh, point and call them ignoramuses who don't know anything about the nation they want to run into the ground.
Tell them I sent you...
Not hardly...
It's Final Jeopardy and the category is: US Myths and Fallacies
The answer is, "All of them." You have thirty seconds. Please put your answer in the form of a question.
(30 seconds later)
Right wing, contestant number one, you have thirty trillion dollars and own 85% of the wealth of the United States. What was your answer?
Uh, I said, "How many of the Founding Fathers were Christians?"
Oh, I'm sorry, Right Wing. That is an incorrect answer. The Correct answer is "Which of the Founding Fathers were businessmen?"
That's right, boys and girls and all the ships at sea, our Founding Fathers were Businessmen first, liberals (yes, really, liberals, interested in freedom, democracy and wary of large tyrannical powers that sought to limit personal freedom and choice) and, mostly not too fond of religions.
Now, it must be pointed out that they were against ORGANIZED RELIGIONS. This is an important distinction. They believed in faith, but they adamantly refused to allow a personal faith to interfere in the business of creating a government. They went so far as to put that into the FIRST AMENDMENT in the bill of rights.
You see, organized religions have this habit of screwing up governments. As observed by Thomas Jefferson (you know, the guy who wrote the Declaration of Independence? Third President of the United States? Banged his own slave girl and fathered children with her? THAT Thomas Jefferson?) in a letter to German Baron von Humboldt in 1813:
"History, I believe, furnishes no example of a priest-ridden people maintaining a free civil government. This marks the lowest grade of ignorance, of which their political as well as religious leaders will always avail themselves for their own purpose."Now, let's fast-forward to today. Our right-wingers have availed themselves of the lowest grade of ignorance to manipulate the poor, southerner/mid-westerner for their own purposes.
Now, least you think that perhaps he was talking about corrput politicians and priests and not about religions in general or Christianity in particular, he went on to say at another time:
The score is Reason 2, Religions 0. And proof that not all of the founding fathers were interested in making a "christian nation."
"I have recently been examining all the known superstitions of the world, and do not find in our particular superstition (Christianity) one redeeming feature. They are all alike founded on fables and mythology."
But let us go further and examine the right-wing notion that they were trying to do just that: create a Christian Nation.
They were crafting a nation. They only needed a 2/3 majority to get the work done. And all of the 13 original states had to sign onto the newly drafted Constitution. If we were a nation of people wanting it to be a Christian nation, why didn't they put it in the Constitution? Why, instead, did they specifically and categorically deny the right of the government to dictate what religion a person had. Not only that, but why did they put that prohibition against the government into the very FIRST amendment which became our Bill of Rights? Going one step further to pound this home, why did they make that the FIRST PROVISION OF THAT AMENDMENT IN THE BILL OF RIGHTS? If these were all good and godly men foaming at the mount to create the first truly Christian Nation, why did they go so far out of their way to shoot themselves in the foot on the journey to that religious destiny?
Well, the easy answer is because they weren't that interested in God. In fact, they were so not interested in God, that the word God doesn't appear in the Constitution. Nowhere. Not a peep. In fact, "deity", "Creator" or any reference to anything even remotely of a religious, let alone "christian" nature is glaringly absent from the Constitution - aside from the prohibition on the part of government to create laws based on one.
You think, maybe, they were sending a message?
To refresh your memory:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.Not only did our founding fathers tell the government you can't establish a religion, but it went on to say that you can't pass laws that tell others how to live based on a particular religion or faith since they may have a different faith and that law may interfere in the free exercise of it.
This isn't exactly what I would call "Christian Nation building" here.
The truth of the matter is that the founding fathers saw what the Church of England had done to the people in England (and elsewhere where other religions governed or had a strong hand in the running of a government). They knew that allowing any religion, regardless of who believed in it, or how many, to be able to take power in the government would be a disaster for the free, open society they envisioned.
So why were they so into a free and open society? Aside from a large dose of off-shore repression England engaged in before the Revolutionary war (and for a period of time thereafter, in fact), the founding fathers were BUSINESSMEN. Almost all of them were rich land-owners. Almost all of them were extremely well educated. Almost all of them owned businesses or were heavily invested in them.
In ANY society run by dogma, the clerics only need to decide something is subversive or immoral, then pass a law to outlaw it or restrict it. In a free and open society, people can smoke, drink and fool around howsoever they please. They can indulge in the vices the church often railed against: Smoking, drinking and fooling around. Many of the founding fathers owned (or were invested in) distilleries. Others owned tobacco plantations. Almost all of them owned slaves (something ELSE the churches hated and wanted abolished).
The founding fathers were creating a businessman's paradise, folks, NOT a nation of Christians. The LAST damned thing they wanted was some stupid church to get its meat hooks into the government to shut down their distilleries, make them stop harvesting tobacco (and hemp, by the way), or, heaven forbid, take away their slaves. Profits would plummet.
A cadre of "Christian Nation Builders" they were not.
So the next time you hear a right-winger talk about our found fathers as Christians interested in a Christian nation, you can do what I do: Laugh, point and call them ignoramuses who don't know anything about the nation they want to run into the ground.
Tell them I sent you...
Friday, October 22, 2010
Forgiveness - It's Why We Fight
It struck me recently (yes, it hurt) that humans don't forgive and that lack of forgiveness drives our societies, religions and politics.
Our histories are rife with acts of revenge, blood feuds and grudges held against a people, families or tribes that can last centuries. In some cultures, such demands of vengeance are considered honorable and good. People don't avoid it, they embrace it. We as a people seek revenge instead of justice, demanding not just that biblical limit of only an eye for an eye and only a tooth for a tooth (yes, folks, it's a call for restitution, not bloody retribution - Exodus 21:22-25. And Matthew 5:38-48 says to turn the other cheek anyhow.), but to take the whole body (and then some) for incidents that aren't even criminal in some cases.
Remember the Alamo! Remember Pearl Harbor! Remember the Maine! Remember 9/11!
All of these have been used as rallying cries to inflict harm and damage on people who had nothing to do with the atrocities mentioned. It wasn't uncommon for prisoners to be shot, so the Alamo had no survivors. Pearl Harbor was a strategic mistake in many ways, but would it have made any difference if the Japanese had managed to declare war before the attack? Germany didn't attack us and look what happened there. Millions of Japanese civilians who had nothing to do with the war died. Investigations have since determined that the Maine probably blew up due to a coal dust explosion, but a lot of Spaniards who had nothing to do with it died because of our seeking revenge for it. And 9/11... It was used as a political excuse to go to war with a country we didn't have to fight, resulting in well over a million casualties and countless more people seeking vengeance.
Our tendency to fight first, understand later is what makes humans so dangerous. We kill in haste, repent at leisure, but the problem is that those we kill are often not responsible for what happened to us. And they knew people who hold grudges over friends being killed for something that friend didn't necessarily do. If we throw in the tendency to rationalize our violence (like convince ourselves that because the people who flew planes into the twin towers and the Pentagon were Middle Eastern Muslims that all Middle Eastern Muslims are dangerous and should be exterminated before they do the same to us again), we end up going far and away beyond the eye for an eye concept. When the fact that those being killed have the same reaction to being killed as we do (because to them, they're perfectly justified in killing us) the violence never ends.
Look at the Palestine/Israel conflict. The damned thing's been going on for 62 years. The conflict has raised the stakes so that now, even if the Palestinians got a "home" and all demands on both sides were met, the violence would not end because both sides carry grudges.
This is the essential nature of mankind: Vengeance, revenge, retribution. Making someone hurt and pay for what they did to you. There is no INHERENT goodness in man. There is only the caveman hunched by a fire with a sharpened stick waiting for the tribe from which he stole one of their women to come after him and wipe out his tribe because of it - then kill the woman he stole because she was no longer "pure".
Sound familiar?
Here's the funny thing: We LOVE this stuff. We can't get enough of it. How many movies, books, stories and such are based on the simple concept of over-kill in retaliation for a wrong? We sacrifice horny teens by the gory score at summer blockbusters just to build up the concept that an entity (or person) is bad and deserves to die. While this would be fine in the normal scope of things, the simple fact is humans DON'T KNOW WHEN TO STOP. In real life, if that entity or person was slaughtered in an imaginative and sufficiently gory way, attention would then turn on their friends, associates, family members, religion and/or workplace. How many times has it happened that innocents suffer for what someone they know did?
Way more times than is comfortable to think about.
Let's face it, mankind doesn't WANT to forgive transgressions against it. No one ever believes themselves to be in the wrong. Even if they know they are, they deny it. So they fight, and maim and kill all in the name of righteous retribution for a transgression against them - be it real or imagined. The ridiculous lengths to which we go over this kind of thing is beyond imagination, but sadly not beyond reality.
How many sports fans have attacked and killed other sports fans for what a member of or a whole team did? How many Muslims died in protest over the depiction of their Prophet and how many of them wanted to see the entire West die because of it? An accident in one household can lead to murder in another. There is an inherent lack of perspective when it comes to events such as this that we are not willing to embrace. We seek the "noble cause", the "righteousness of our cause" or some other high-minded rationalization to justify our basic desire to kill people over what we see as harm. Politicians and religious leaders have played on this concept for so long, it is part of our culture and mindset. It's not like we're going to be able to change that anytime soon.
Now, I'm not advocating that we all take a Christian point of view about forgiveness. After all, reality doesn't work that way in the first place and in the second, not everyone can stomach the Christian morality. Forgiveness isn't about saying, "What you did was bad but I forgive you." Real, true human forgiveness should be about saying something to the effect of, "I won't take it out on people who aren't responsible, and once you are punished for what you have done, I won't hold a grudge."
Be aware that, in the human mind, the balance of scales regarding acts demanding revenge are skewed. Therefore, it's necessary to seek a proportionate punishment for the act on the individuals actually responsible for the act. This is the root of the beginning to understand real human forgiveness. It's a forgiveness that is realistically attainable for most people which can help contain the mindless, directionless violence that often accompanies vengeful acts.
Mankind will never give up the desire to seek retribution. At least not anytime in the next few thousand years. But a "civilized" species can learn to moderate that desire for revenge by acquiring some perspective and spending a lot of time in anger management lessons.
We COULD, I suppose, get into a long, involved discussion about "justice" as an alternative to revenge, but let's face it, revenge balances the scales in the mind of the one seeking revenge. Justice is strictly something society does and really doesn't address an individual's harm. Learning "forgiveness" is the simple act of seeking a revenge that balances the scales in proportion to the act being avenged and then moving on without letting the original act consume your life or bringing others into the picture.
Forgiveness: Proportionate revenge with the perspective of an outsider.
Now let's examine the proper application of this idea, since in religions we get a lot of rules without a lot of ideas in exactly how to go about this in real life.
To begin with, let's quantify what we're talking about: Personal harm should be defined only as acts intentionally directed at you specifically intended to inflict emotional, physical or mental damage. If it isn't personal harm, let it go.
First of all, examine the act. This is the anger management part. Were you hurt? Was property damaged? Was there any lasting harm to you? If not, get over it. You only have one shot at this life. Filling it up with petty garbage from slights and insults that have done nothing to you will only screw up your life and I'm sure you have better things to do than to have your life screwed up by something which did you no personal harm.
Always think first. Not about how many tiny bloody bits you can carve someone into, but about what happened in proportion to what you want to do. Did someone in another land do something you don't like? Did it hurt you personally? If so, how much? Is it righteous indignation you feel? Let that go. Others don't share your faith and if you don't respect their right to have a different one, you don't deserve to have your faith respected by others, either. Did they disrespect your faith? Fine, let them. If you think your faith can't handle the disrespect of others, then you need to find a stronger faith. Their disrespect for your faith doesn't hurt you or your faith. Are they killing you over your faith? Go for the ones who are doing the killing, not the ones you think have the same faith.
The point here is that what you believe is personal harm usually isn't. The other point is that you need to know who is actually responsible for inflicting that personal harm because it's usually not the ones you hurt back.
Stop and think about things, folks. That's how to implement this whole concept. Revenge is a dish best served cold and you can't do that when you're enraged. Once you cool off, you may realize that it wasn't an act deserving of any retribution at all. I don't advocate forgiveness as a free pass. Human nature demands punishment for acts that cause harm. But we do need to learn some perspective about what we think is harm and be proportionate in seeking any retribution. We don't swat flies with shovels or spank babies with axes. Why do we do that kind of thing when it comes to revenge? Perspective and proportion. Those are realistic interim behavioral goals that humans can actually achieve on our paths of spiritual exploration and evolution. Rome wasn't built in a day. Human instincts have had millions of years of evolution to get to this point and only thousands of years to get used to civilized behavior.
As for me, I think about revenge a lot, but my personal philosophy doesn't let me seek retribution without incurring grievous harm on myself. For the most part, I let the universe sort it out. It takes patience but it keeps the dry cleaning bills removing blood stains to a minimum.
Our histories are rife with acts of revenge, blood feuds and grudges held against a people, families or tribes that can last centuries. In some cultures, such demands of vengeance are considered honorable and good. People don't avoid it, they embrace it. We as a people seek revenge instead of justice, demanding not just that biblical limit of only an eye for an eye and only a tooth for a tooth (yes, folks, it's a call for restitution, not bloody retribution - Exodus 21:22-25. And Matthew 5:38-48 says to turn the other cheek anyhow.), but to take the whole body (and then some) for incidents that aren't even criminal in some cases.
Remember the Alamo! Remember Pearl Harbor! Remember the Maine! Remember 9/11!
All of these have been used as rallying cries to inflict harm and damage on people who had nothing to do with the atrocities mentioned. It wasn't uncommon for prisoners to be shot, so the Alamo had no survivors. Pearl Harbor was a strategic mistake in many ways, but would it have made any difference if the Japanese had managed to declare war before the attack? Germany didn't attack us and look what happened there. Millions of Japanese civilians who had nothing to do with the war died. Investigations have since determined that the Maine probably blew up due to a coal dust explosion, but a lot of Spaniards who had nothing to do with it died because of our seeking revenge for it. And 9/11... It was used as a political excuse to go to war with a country we didn't have to fight, resulting in well over a million casualties and countless more people seeking vengeance.
Our tendency to fight first, understand later is what makes humans so dangerous. We kill in haste, repent at leisure, but the problem is that those we kill are often not responsible for what happened to us. And they knew people who hold grudges over friends being killed for something that friend didn't necessarily do. If we throw in the tendency to rationalize our violence (like convince ourselves that because the people who flew planes into the twin towers and the Pentagon were Middle Eastern Muslims that all Middle Eastern Muslims are dangerous and should be exterminated before they do the same to us again), we end up going far and away beyond the eye for an eye concept. When the fact that those being killed have the same reaction to being killed as we do (because to them, they're perfectly justified in killing us) the violence never ends.
Look at the Palestine/Israel conflict. The damned thing's been going on for 62 years. The conflict has raised the stakes so that now, even if the Palestinians got a "home" and all demands on both sides were met, the violence would not end because both sides carry grudges.
This is the essential nature of mankind: Vengeance, revenge, retribution. Making someone hurt and pay for what they did to you. There is no INHERENT goodness in man. There is only the caveman hunched by a fire with a sharpened stick waiting for the tribe from which he stole one of their women to come after him and wipe out his tribe because of it - then kill the woman he stole because she was no longer "pure".
Sound familiar?
Here's the funny thing: We LOVE this stuff. We can't get enough of it. How many movies, books, stories and such are based on the simple concept of over-kill in retaliation for a wrong? We sacrifice horny teens by the gory score at summer blockbusters just to build up the concept that an entity (or person) is bad and deserves to die. While this would be fine in the normal scope of things, the simple fact is humans DON'T KNOW WHEN TO STOP. In real life, if that entity or person was slaughtered in an imaginative and sufficiently gory way, attention would then turn on their friends, associates, family members, religion and/or workplace. How many times has it happened that innocents suffer for what someone they know did?
Way more times than is comfortable to think about.
Let's face it, mankind doesn't WANT to forgive transgressions against it. No one ever believes themselves to be in the wrong. Even if they know they are, they deny it. So they fight, and maim and kill all in the name of righteous retribution for a transgression against them - be it real or imagined. The ridiculous lengths to which we go over this kind of thing is beyond imagination, but sadly not beyond reality.
How many sports fans have attacked and killed other sports fans for what a member of or a whole team did? How many Muslims died in protest over the depiction of their Prophet and how many of them wanted to see the entire West die because of it? An accident in one household can lead to murder in another. There is an inherent lack of perspective when it comes to events such as this that we are not willing to embrace. We seek the "noble cause", the "righteousness of our cause" or some other high-minded rationalization to justify our basic desire to kill people over what we see as harm. Politicians and religious leaders have played on this concept for so long, it is part of our culture and mindset. It's not like we're going to be able to change that anytime soon.
Now, I'm not advocating that we all take a Christian point of view about forgiveness. After all, reality doesn't work that way in the first place and in the second, not everyone can stomach the Christian morality. Forgiveness isn't about saying, "What you did was bad but I forgive you." Real, true human forgiveness should be about saying something to the effect of, "I won't take it out on people who aren't responsible, and once you are punished for what you have done, I won't hold a grudge."
Be aware that, in the human mind, the balance of scales regarding acts demanding revenge are skewed. Therefore, it's necessary to seek a proportionate punishment for the act on the individuals actually responsible for the act. This is the root of the beginning to understand real human forgiveness. It's a forgiveness that is realistically attainable for most people which can help contain the mindless, directionless violence that often accompanies vengeful acts.
Mankind will never give up the desire to seek retribution. At least not anytime in the next few thousand years. But a "civilized" species can learn to moderate that desire for revenge by acquiring some perspective and spending a lot of time in anger management lessons.
We COULD, I suppose, get into a long, involved discussion about "justice" as an alternative to revenge, but let's face it, revenge balances the scales in the mind of the one seeking revenge. Justice is strictly something society does and really doesn't address an individual's harm. Learning "forgiveness" is the simple act of seeking a revenge that balances the scales in proportion to the act being avenged and then moving on without letting the original act consume your life or bringing others into the picture.
Forgiveness: Proportionate revenge with the perspective of an outsider.
Now let's examine the proper application of this idea, since in religions we get a lot of rules without a lot of ideas in exactly how to go about this in real life.
To begin with, let's quantify what we're talking about: Personal harm should be defined only as acts intentionally directed at you specifically intended to inflict emotional, physical or mental damage. If it isn't personal harm, let it go.
First of all, examine the act. This is the anger management part. Were you hurt? Was property damaged? Was there any lasting harm to you? If not, get over it. You only have one shot at this life. Filling it up with petty garbage from slights and insults that have done nothing to you will only screw up your life and I'm sure you have better things to do than to have your life screwed up by something which did you no personal harm.
Always think first. Not about how many tiny bloody bits you can carve someone into, but about what happened in proportion to what you want to do. Did someone in another land do something you don't like? Did it hurt you personally? If so, how much? Is it righteous indignation you feel? Let that go. Others don't share your faith and if you don't respect their right to have a different one, you don't deserve to have your faith respected by others, either. Did they disrespect your faith? Fine, let them. If you think your faith can't handle the disrespect of others, then you need to find a stronger faith. Their disrespect for your faith doesn't hurt you or your faith. Are they killing you over your faith? Go for the ones who are doing the killing, not the ones you think have the same faith.
The point here is that what you believe is personal harm usually isn't. The other point is that you need to know who is actually responsible for inflicting that personal harm because it's usually not the ones you hurt back.
Stop and think about things, folks. That's how to implement this whole concept. Revenge is a dish best served cold and you can't do that when you're enraged. Once you cool off, you may realize that it wasn't an act deserving of any retribution at all. I don't advocate forgiveness as a free pass. Human nature demands punishment for acts that cause harm. But we do need to learn some perspective about what we think is harm and be proportionate in seeking any retribution. We don't swat flies with shovels or spank babies with axes. Why do we do that kind of thing when it comes to revenge? Perspective and proportion. Those are realistic interim behavioral goals that humans can actually achieve on our paths of spiritual exploration and evolution. Rome wasn't built in a day. Human instincts have had millions of years of evolution to get to this point and only thousands of years to get used to civilized behavior.
As for me, I think about revenge a lot, but my personal philosophy doesn't let me seek retribution without incurring grievous harm on myself. For the most part, I let the universe sort it out. It takes patience but it keeps the dry cleaning bills removing blood stains to a minimum.
Friday, November 21, 2008
This Faith is rated R - 11/21/2008
I've never had any love for
religions that say 'you must believe this way', or that 'ours is the
only way to believe' or some other such nonsense. In an infinite
universe, having one religion and only one religion being the 'one
true faith' seems rather limited for an omnipotent being. I'm
reminded of the South Park episode where St. Peter tells the
character "The correct answer [to which faith was the 'right'
one] is 'the Mormons' ". With 7 billion names of God, and almost
as many religions in which people believe and have faith as strong as
any reader here may have, it seems rather chaotic and unlikely that
God would leave it up to us to figure out which is right unless the
simple and expedient method is that all are 'right'.
But religions themselves - especially those that are more cult-like such as the snake worshipers, Quakers, any radical Islamic sect, etc. - should be a matter of choice and not indoctrination.
Imagine a government indoctrinating your children in the secular world, keeping them from practicing any particular religion or faith, until they're legally allowed to vote. Now, imagine a government indoctrinating your children in one faith, even if it's not the one you practice.
Which is worse?
The fact is, a religion is an ADULT choice. Children are indoctrinated in whatever faith you happen to practice at the time because you practice it. In most cases, religions demand the indoctrination of your children in the faith whether you want to or not. This, of course, ensures a plentiful and endless supply of the faithful to fill the pews and coffers of the faith.
But what if we restricted religion to adults only?
There's legislation being considered to ensure that those religions which rely on faith for their medical treatment (and consequently experience a staggeringly higher than average death rate) must take children to see a doctor.
Good idea, you say. Why should children suffer because mom and dad are too whacked out on a cult to do the right thing and get them conventional medical treatment for life-threatening conditions?
So how is this different than the government keeping your kids from learning all about your religion until they're legally old enough to make adult decisions?
The fact is, it doesn't. And the point is, it SHOULD HAPPEN.
Religion shouldn't be about what mom and dad believe. It's SUPPOSED to be about a person's individual relationship with (insert your choice of deity here). How can a child make that kind of decision? More to the point, how would a child know that Mom and Dad are a bit too whacked to know what's right for any of them?
They don't. They just do what Mom and Dad do because that's how humans are hard-wired. And if Mom and Dad are idiots, the child will follow idiotic practices. Such is the way of the world.
I guess the bottom line is, if you want to save the children, you have to start by saving your own first and NOT indoctrinate them in your faith. Encourage them to find their own paths. Be objective and dispassionate about all faiths and answer questions honestly and without the 'do this or spend the rest of eternity - which is a REALLY LONG TIME - suffering endless torment' BS that keeps the sheep in line.
For those who say you can't teach morality without teaching religion, I say bullshit. You can teach a person to obey the law, treat others with at least a minimum amount of respect, to like one's self and to play nice with others without ANY religion at all. All you have to do is live the example you want to set. Your kids will turn out fine.
My parents had hypocritical tendencies when it came to religion, and the more I saw the contradictions between what they did and what the religion said, the less I liked the idea of the religion. My parents were equipped for the real world. The religion (like most today) was not. I ended up living their example and it took me a long time to find a faith with which I am comfortable. I really HATE hypocrisy. Were I to have kids (and if that ever happens, it will prove God exists and has a sadistic sense of humor to boot), they would not be taught my religion. I would answer any questions they have about any religion honestly and without bias and encourage them to make up their own minds as to what path to take.
This, by the way, is MANDATED in my religion, which is obviously NOT Christian, Islamic or Jewish. You can only walk one path - yours. It is a personal choice and if I deliberately interfered with another's life path, that's bad for both of us. Hence my distaste for evangelical religions of any kind.
So don't indoctrinate your kids. Don't expect them, let alone demand them, to follow in your faith's footsteps. I'd rather see a law passed restricting the practicing of a religion and/or imposing a religious dogma on another to adults only. An adult has a choice. Children, often times, do not. And when it comes to indoctrination, children will think they're doing the right thing only because everyone they know is doing the same thing, when, in fact, it's a very, very bad thing. Let adults figure out what religion (if any) they want to follow and leave the kids alone. In the end, making an informed choice in religion is better than paying tens of thousands of dollars in therapy to get over a childhood ruined by overly zealous parents and their fascination with a cult, or dying because the parents thought God could cure childhood diabetes or any other treatable, but eventually deadly ailment with prayer alone.
But religions themselves - especially those that are more cult-like such as the snake worshipers, Quakers, any radical Islamic sect, etc. - should be a matter of choice and not indoctrination.
Imagine a government indoctrinating your children in the secular world, keeping them from practicing any particular religion or faith, until they're legally allowed to vote. Now, imagine a government indoctrinating your children in one faith, even if it's not the one you practice.
Which is worse?
The fact is, a religion is an ADULT choice. Children are indoctrinated in whatever faith you happen to practice at the time because you practice it. In most cases, religions demand the indoctrination of your children in the faith whether you want to or not. This, of course, ensures a plentiful and endless supply of the faithful to fill the pews and coffers of the faith.
But what if we restricted religion to adults only?
There's legislation being considered to ensure that those religions which rely on faith for their medical treatment (and consequently experience a staggeringly higher than average death rate) must take children to see a doctor.
Good idea, you say. Why should children suffer because mom and dad are too whacked out on a cult to do the right thing and get them conventional medical treatment for life-threatening conditions?
So how is this different than the government keeping your kids from learning all about your religion until they're legally old enough to make adult decisions?
The fact is, it doesn't. And the point is, it SHOULD HAPPEN.
Religion shouldn't be about what mom and dad believe. It's SUPPOSED to be about a person's individual relationship with (insert your choice of deity here). How can a child make that kind of decision? More to the point, how would a child know that Mom and Dad are a bit too whacked to know what's right for any of them?
They don't. They just do what Mom and Dad do because that's how humans are hard-wired. And if Mom and Dad are idiots, the child will follow idiotic practices. Such is the way of the world.
I guess the bottom line is, if you want to save the children, you have to start by saving your own first and NOT indoctrinate them in your faith. Encourage them to find their own paths. Be objective and dispassionate about all faiths and answer questions honestly and without the 'do this or spend the rest of eternity - which is a REALLY LONG TIME - suffering endless torment' BS that keeps the sheep in line.
For those who say you can't teach morality without teaching religion, I say bullshit. You can teach a person to obey the law, treat others with at least a minimum amount of respect, to like one's self and to play nice with others without ANY religion at all. All you have to do is live the example you want to set. Your kids will turn out fine.
My parents had hypocritical tendencies when it came to religion, and the more I saw the contradictions between what they did and what the religion said, the less I liked the idea of the religion. My parents were equipped for the real world. The religion (like most today) was not. I ended up living their example and it took me a long time to find a faith with which I am comfortable. I really HATE hypocrisy. Were I to have kids (and if that ever happens, it will prove God exists and has a sadistic sense of humor to boot), they would not be taught my religion. I would answer any questions they have about any religion honestly and without bias and encourage them to make up their own minds as to what path to take.
This, by the way, is MANDATED in my religion, which is obviously NOT Christian, Islamic or Jewish. You can only walk one path - yours. It is a personal choice and if I deliberately interfered with another's life path, that's bad for both of us. Hence my distaste for evangelical religions of any kind.
So don't indoctrinate your kids. Don't expect them, let alone demand them, to follow in your faith's footsteps. I'd rather see a law passed restricting the practicing of a religion and/or imposing a religious dogma on another to adults only. An adult has a choice. Children, often times, do not. And when it comes to indoctrination, children will think they're doing the right thing only because everyone they know is doing the same thing, when, in fact, it's a very, very bad thing. Let adults figure out what religion (if any) they want to follow and leave the kids alone. In the end, making an informed choice in religion is better than paying tens of thousands of dollars in therapy to get over a childhood ruined by overly zealous parents and their fascination with a cult, or dying because the parents thought God could cure childhood diabetes or any other treatable, but eventually deadly ailment with prayer alone.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)