Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts

Friday, October 29, 2010

A Time-Out for Time-Outs

As usual, this idea is controversial, especially if you believe in the New Age idea of molly-coddling children. If you have a mass-produced bumper sticker on the back of your car that lauds your child's completely irrelevant and minor scholastic achievements, and you read this, you will probably think I'm utterly barbaric. You're probably right, but then, that's the whole reason for this post.

Here's the reason for the post: I DO believe in child abuse.

Let me rephrase that so the politically correct types can stop hyperventilating in preparation for an apoplectic fit of yuppie rage.

I believe that the responsible application of corporal punishment on children for offenses which merit criminal punishment in adults is both a more effective and more suitable deterrent to the possibility of re-offending than the current method of punishment of using "time outs" and the restriction of other privileges.

Lying, cheating, stealing, fighting, public disturbances, talking back; all of these are offenses at some place for an adult for which a civil or criminal penalty is imposed. Most kids these days will get a "time out" for them. Most kids will then re-offend and do the same thing. If, as an adult, you're getting back-talk from a five year old, something is wrong with this picture.

Let's look at child-rearing, then and now, and explode a few myths along the way. This might help put things in proper perspective.

Back when I was growing up (a time somewhat after the last Ice Age, before the Computer Age, when Leave It To Beaver, Gilligan's Island and Star Trek - the one with William Shatner as captain of the Enterprise - weren't in reruns), kids played outside with toys that sparked imagination. The term "helicopter parenting" wouldn't appear for at least four decades and a Bush was household shrubbery. No one talked much about the latest kidnapping, rape and murder of children (though, actually, it happened more often then than now). No one had GPS and cell phones to keep track of their little darlings. School officials were allowed to beat the living crap out of you if you got out of line. (okay, okay, they could spank you - but if you saw my Assistant Principle you knew that if he were to spank you, your odds of survival were the same as those of the proverbial snowball in Hell). While some places had kids acting out, for the most part, schools were gun-free, knife-free and generally well ordered. Crime, for my generation, started a decline. The criminals were people who were either over-the-top abused or were never spanked.

Then we enter into the age of the Time Out.

Now we have children in gangs (lots more gang activity today than back then). We have a new way of teaching everyone that everyone wins in school, when in real life, practically no one wins and no one gets out alive. If someone acts out, they get a "time out" which is a period of not too unpleasant boredom to "think about what they did". What they actually think about is how not to get caught the next time. Corporal punishment was removed from schools and as a result, metal detectors and police were installed in its place. But with the plethora of entertainment devices a child has today, even if they're sent to their rooms, it's not like that's all that much of a punishment. Sitting them in a corner is no more effective than being bored on a Sunday afternoon.

You see, my generation didn't enjoy getting the crap beaten out of us (well, that's how we thought of it at least). We were thinking way too short-term. We felt the pain and thought to ourselves, "Isn't there a better, more enlightened way to direct a child's behavior than by inflicting pain?" We vowed never to beat our kids because we were beaten. But we never really thought about the consequences of our beatings on our behaviors. For the most part, we grew up to be fine examples of modern society. We may have thought of it as having done it in spite of the way punishment was meted out to us. Few ever stopped to consider the probability it was BECAUSE of the punishment meted out to us.

Yes, it was unpleasant, but it was memorable. VERY memorable. And in that is the key to punishment. Is a "time out" memorable? Let's put it this way, if you were ever standing around on a Sunday afternoon, say around three fifteen in the afternoon between games on TV and after mowing the lawn, with nothing to do, you're experiencing the exact same thing as some kid who is sitting in a time-out. I know I can think of a time or two when I was bored, but what kind of an impact does that make on my desire or willingness to break a law (or rule, transgression, etc)?

Pretty much none. It wasn't memorable. It was boring, yes, but it wasn't a trial of any kind. There was no lasting impression made from a time-out.

But a paddling?

Talk to anyone with gray hair. Almost universally, they'll remember being paddled, spanked or in some other way physically touched in order to inflict a mild to moderate amount of pain with no permanent physical harm. And if done right, it will be not only memorable, but effective as well.

This segues nicely into the fact that getting spanked has a right way and a wrong way. The wrong way is to haul off and beat the crap out of a kid the instant the transgression happens. Yes, it's viscerally satisfying on a deep, emotional level to strike at the source of one's irritation, but a civilized society usually refrains from such indulgences. The best way to beat the crap out of a kid so that it is a lesson that is memorable and effective (preferably without requiring a doctor's visit or hospitalization) as opposed to abuse is to be calm, be timely, be consistent, have rules and explain what's happening, when and why.

So, step 1. Rules.

A child can't know when they've broken rules unless they know the rules ahead of time. Ignorance of the rule is no excuse. So a wise parent will have rules and, just as importantly, punishments for breaking those rules. Make sure there's a "when in doubt" rule to cover all bases.

Now that the boundaries are laid, crossing them should always require a parental review. Was it justified? If so, the boundaries have to be moved. If not, it was a violation and punishment is required. That's the consistency part. Look over the transgression. Yes, kids will be kids. I really do get that. But kids need to learn the limits and what better way than to put an electric fence on it - make them stop, look, be very careful if they're going to cross that line and understand that if they screw up, they get zapped. Be consistent in applying the rules and don't be secretive about them.

Next, make punishment a BIG THING. A fast slap on the butt in the marketplace (aside from probably drawing the attention of Child Protection Services) isn't going to leave much of an impression on the child (no pun intended). But if you discover a transgression, treat it as if they're an adult. Depending on the severity of the transgression, place them under "arrest" with restrictions on toys, activities, privileges, etc. Sit them down in a trial. Tell them what they did wrong, why it was wrong, let them argue their case and show them the error of their ways. Then pronounce sentence. Let them think about THAT for a bit. Finally, commence with the bea..., er, spanking, in a calm, measured, dispassionate way. Do not tell them that it hurts you more than it hurts them. They won't believe you. Do not sympathize with them. The lesson won't be learned properly.

When it's over, don't hold grudges.

The point here is that if a punishment isn't memorable, what's to stop a kid from doing it again and again? If there's too much punishment, it becomes difficult for a child to know what's right and wrong. Not every transgression merits a spanking, of course. Every child is different, as well, so one must know whether physical pain, administered in a measured, controlled fashion will be the most effective deterrent to that child's case of bad behavior.

And if you don't have the kind of time to do this, you should give your kids up for adoption. They need parents, not playmates.

Now, as much as I believe in child abuse for kids, I believe even stronger that such punishments should extend to adults. Only with adults instead of safely tucking it away behind prison walls where only whispered stories of various levels of truth leak out from time to time in specials designed to show how awful it is in them, we need to be public, open and visually brutal.

Adults aren't children. They generally don't live to please an authority figure. They have a greater ability to rationalize away criminal behaviors. Adults are capable of a level of brutality far exceeding that of children. Meeting this brutality with a controlled brutality is the only way to mete out a punishment of sufficient intensity to be memorable in such a way that one would NOT wish to experience it again. I think public floggings for relatively minor offenses which would normally merit a jail sentence should be the norm. The number of strokes would depend on the offense. It should be administered by a machine (for the sake of consistency and safety) which is physically constrained from exceeding a safe "per-stroke" level of force. A medic should be on hand to ensure that no permanent damage is done (aside from the potential of scarring unless a scar-free way of flogging someone can be found).

Why flogging? Because it's visual, visceral and brutal. It's MEMORABLE, both for those who undergo it and those who witness it. And it's not an experience one would wish to repeat.

While we're on the subject, I'm NOT an advocate of the Death Penalty. Yes, it gets rid of unwanted vermin, but sometimes they throw out the baby with the trash - innocent people HAVE been executed in the US. That's very bad juju. Instead, I advocate a "Prison TV" channel for people who would otherwise have been executed. Every prison should have their own station, which the viewer can access and control, to watch what happens to a lifer in a prison. No privacy. No escape. Public humiliation. It's been proven that the death penalty isn't a deterrent. But maybe something like this will satisfy society's desire for vengeance.

One thing for sure: It's memorable.

The fact is, the criminals of today's society need a good spanking. If it's memorable enough, painful enough and embarrassing enough, it may have more of an impact than the way we punish criminals today.

Okay, the yuppie, new-age, easily bruised sensibilities people can now go and have some white Zin and tofu cakes and get on with your lives. Keep repeating to yourselves, "It's only a blog... It's only a blog... It's only a blog..."

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Beating Mind Games: Why Johnny Will Never Be A Genius

This post will probably offend a lot of people, but if you can get past the resentment (mine and yours), I think the point is both valid and one needing to be addressed.

As someone with an above average IQ (Okay, WAY above average and yes, I've been tested.), I find the fact that geniuses are universally hated and reviled, bullied and put upon to be rather depressing. Let's face it, we as a nation, revere strength and physical power over brains and mental agility. The former are muscular bad-boys with good looks who are glorified on the field of combat (well, sports fields in mock-combat) while the latter are bespectacled, acne-scarred social misfits relegated to musty, dark rooms, pouring over stacks of moldy old tomes in the search of something the stereotype will typically say is relevant only to the searcher. The former gets the girl and his face on magazines until he's too old for ESPN. The latter gets the Nobel Prize, and pretty much complete obscurity after that.

People call geniuses social misfits (at best), mock them, deride them, insult them and yet without them - that top 10% of brain-power among human kind - civilization as we know it would cease to exist. Without the thinkers, the doers could only do so much. In warfare, if you eliminate the planners, the army can't fulfill its role and is eventually defeated by the side with planners. Better planners will win over poorer planners.

In schools, mediocrity is ENCOURAGED, if not enforced, by the social structure. The person who skews the average by actually learning the material better than anyone else is vilified and outcast from the rest. Never mind that they are more likely to make more money, be more successful in life and have the last laugh at the 20 year reunion, they're hated by their peers all their lives. Given this proclivity in our social expectations and traditions, it's hardly any wonder that they tend to form intellectual clubs.

Geniuses tend to group with other geniuses because, finally, there is a new peer group that actually understands what's being said as well as one in which the peer group has a mutual understanding of the life experiences of others in that group. They don't talk football stats or which steroid is least likely to turn one's testicles into useless raisins. They talk Cobal, or Klingon, or Chemistry. Like everyone else, they have mutual interests. Unlike everyone else, those interests have little or nothing to do with physical prowess (except in sex, but that's just the human condition of wanting what you can't get).

The similarities between the two groups - the physicals and the geniuses - are numerous. It is the mentality of the two which is so vastly different. Geniuses think. Their activities involve brain-work. Physicals do. Their activities involve muscle work or relatively mindless entertainment. Because of this mentality gap, the two groups don't relate well to one another. And because of the fact there are ten physicals to every genius, general society is made up of physicals who take a dim view to thinking.

Now, least you think this is a skewed perception consider this: The person most likely to get beaten to a pulp in school is above average in IQ. The evil character is almost always portrayed as an "evil genius". Even "Brainiac" was an outcast among the super heroes. Politicians especially do NOT want an educated, smart electorate. God forbid they have one because then they'd actually have to come through with their campaign promises. People would remember them. They'd also have to stay on their best behaviors, because educated people aren't about second chances when these elected officials screwed up so badly the first time. They can't lie to them (smart people actually bother to check snarky things like facts and figures, starting with the hypothesis that most politicians are lying in the first place in some way). They can't twist the truth (for the same reason). Smart people are usually smarter than the politicians.

And so, because society, and their leaders, are generally made up of physical types whose brain-power is less than equal to those of the geniuses, they make life very hard on the geniuses. Everything reflects the bias against being smart, against being well educated, and against having a point of view that differs from what these physical types have decided is 'normal'. Mediocrity is the goal. If excellence is to be seen, it must be a physical feat because they can see it. Mental feats require people to understand what they were, why they were done and how it may effect them. That requires thinking on the part of society in general and, as we have already established, society in general isn't really cut out for that kind of thing.

"ELITIST!!!" you scream.

"Damn straight," I reply mildly.

Consider this: Most of you will never understand quantum relationships or how faster than light communication is not only possible, but is being tested now.

No amount of ditch digging, wrestle-mania, pro-sports or any other physical act is going to make this register in the minds of most people. These who can't conceive of such notions are the people who deny global warming, believe in politicians or political pundits as if those people are saying or going to do anything other than what it takes to get elected and generally go around beating up the very people who actually understand what's going on. Let's face it, most of you don't understand the technology you use every day - even the exact means necessary for you to read these words on your screen are little more than a vague notion that it's "like TV". (It isn't, by the way. It may look like a duck and quack like a duck, but it's not a duck.)

Now, it's not that you HAVE to understand these things. You don't. You're probably a doer (though one could argue that doers are out doing and thinkers are out thinking, and most people who bother to read are thinkers, which means this blog post is being read by the wrong people, but isn't it nice to have someone who understands your plight and is willing to put it out there?). Doers have to do.

Yet it's up to the thinkers to invent this technology, find those medical cures, design those buildings and cars and motorcycles and sports safety equipment. I'll bet most people could name the winner of last year's world series (or who's in the playoffs this year) than can say who discovered Penicillin which has saved more lives than will ever WATCH those games. (Just so you don't have to Google it, Alexander Flemming is credited with the discovery in 1928, and awarded the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1945 which he shared with two others who helped him develop the antibiotic from the penicillin mold. Ian Flemming (no relation) invented James Bond. The two Flemmings are often mistaken for the same person.)

So while doers make the world go around, it's the thinkers that enable them to keep it spinning, making things faster, better, stronger for everyone. We each have our roles to play in the grand scheme of things and the thinkers recognize this. It would be nice if the doers were less inclined to beat the crap out of the thinkers, though. Just because you don't understand it, doesn't mean it's bad. We know you don't like change or new things. But we're thinkers. That's what we do. We make things better and by doing so, change the old things. You are doers. You will learn to do with the new better than you did with the old. Just take a deep breath, let it out slowly, follow the instructions (I admit we thinkers could write them so you can actually understand them better) and you'll be fine.

In the meantime, buy a thinker or two a beer. After all, it was a thinker who invented the stuff in the first place...

Saturday, June 16, 2007

We are our brother's killer - 06/16/2007


Mankind can't get along.

This is a relatively sweeping statement, but in essence it's true. Oh, sure, various groups can get along most of the time, and the majority tend to go about their business without resorting to lethal levels of violence, but on the whole, Mankind will never get along.

Why do I say this? Because Mankind is made up of individuals and individuals don't always get along with everyone else. Any group of individuals (defined as three or more people) will sub-divide into another, smaller group in SOME way. Ultimately, someone will be left standing alone, either by preference or by group design. This doesn't necessarily mean that these sub-divided groups are all mutually hostile to each other - after all, they ARE part of a larger group - but the fact that they do sub-divide into groups with non mutual views shows the inherent fragmentation that is a natural instinct of Humanity.

Even if you can find someone who gets alone with EVERYONE, not everyone else will get along with them. Hence the problem persists.

Insofar as mutual cooperation goes, people CAN get together for short times to cooperate toward a mutually desired goal. But after that, things always fall apart. And given the wide range of human behaviors, it's inevitable that some will resort to violence. The question is, WHY?

No one will ever get along with everyone else all of the time. This means that no matter how much violence you apply toward one group to get them to cooperate, there will be individuals in that group who violently oppose mutual cooperation. But since it's much easier to be violent than it is to find the ways and means of mutual cooperation (including tolerating one another's non-violent, but differing behaviors), violence will persist as the first choice of action for those who oppose mutual cooperation.

Now, the key word here is 'mutual'. Mutual cooperation. This doesn't mean that one side wins and another side must cooperate with the first side. This means both sides (or all sides, regardless of numbers) find common ground in which their differences can be tolerated. But that takes too much effort and even if it's found, some swinging dick in some group is going to find something intolerable about it and do something violent about it.

So the fact is, that though the vast majority of us can actually find something upon which we can mutually agree, there will always be fringe groups who can't, and will express their displeasure over the situation violently. Will it change the situation? No. Governments can be swayed. People can't. And until we all learn that people hold the power, and learn how to deal with people, we are all going to be our brother's killer.